Home
/
Reviews
/
Best Recruiting CRM Software

12 Best CRM Software for Recruitment in 2026

Check out my candid reviews and comparisons of the best recruitment CRM software, including options for enterprises as well as startups and SMBs.

Anh Nguyen
Written by
Anh Nguyen
Ex-Tech Recruiter, Senior HR Tech Researcher, Writer & Editor
Contributing Experts
No items found.
We are a reader supported site with strict editorial standards, clicks may earn a fee which supports our testing. Learn More
Last Updated: Jul 23, 2026
TOP
AI-native recruiting CRM with omnichannel sync and auto-enrichment
Spott
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.2
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
AI-native recruiting CRM with omnichannel sync and auto-enrichment
Spott
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.2
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
Best for all-in-one recruiting operations at small agencies
Recruit CRM
4.1
Popularity Score
4.7
User Score
4.4
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
Best for all-in-one recruiting operations at small agencies
Recruit CRM
4.1
Popularity Score
4.7
User Score
4.4
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
Best for talent engagement and sourcing
Gem
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.6
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
Best for talent engagement and sourcing
Gem
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.6
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
Top freelance management platform with AOR and payments in 190 countries
Worksuite
4.0
Popularity Score
4.6
User Score
4.3
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
Top freelance management platform with AOR and payments in 190 countries
Worksuite
4.0
Popularity Score
4.6
User Score
4.3
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
SMB-focused CRM with solid UX
Popularity Score
User Score
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
SMB-focused CRM with solid UX
Popularity Score
User Score
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
Highly scalable payroll and HR for solopreneurs and SMBs
Paychex
4.1
Popularity Score
3.9
User Score
4.1
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
Highly scalable payroll and HR for solopreneurs and SMBs
Paychex
4.1
Popularity Score
3.9
User Score
4.1
Product  Score
Learn More

Best Recruiting CRM Software

SmartRecruitersBest for managing large, branded talent communities
BullhornBest for re-engaging legacy candidates already in your ATS
ManatalBest for SMBs seeking budget-friendly ATS and CRM software
LoxoBest for outbound recruiting powered by built-in contact data
JobAdderBest for extensive integration partner network
HelloraAI recruiting CRM software for U.S. healthcare hiring
RecruiterflowBest for talent nurture automation in agency environments
CrelateBest for power users who depend on advanced resume search

Humanly

: Best for AI-powered candidate calibration and filtering

TOP
AI-native recruiting CRM with omnichannel sync and auto-enrichment
Spott
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.2
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
AI-native recruiting CRM with omnichannel sync and auto-enrichment
Spott
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.2
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
Best for all-in-one recruiting operations at small agencies
Recruit CRM
4.1
Popularity Score
4.7
User Score
4.4
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
Best for all-in-one recruiting operations at small agencies
Recruit CRM
4.1
Popularity Score
4.7
User Score
4.4
Product  Score
Learn More
TOP
Best for talent engagement and sourcing
Gem
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.6
Product  Score
Visit Website
TOP
Best for talent engagement and sourcing
Gem
4.0
Popularity Score
4.8
User Score
4.6
Product  Score
Learn More
Over 3 million HR leaders trust our advice

Introduction to Recruiting CRM

When picturing the best ally for a recruiter to nurture and sustain strong talent relationships, recruiting CRM is the only name I have in mind.

Unlike applicant tracking systems (ATS), which focus on managing candidates currently in the application process, recruitment CRM leans towards building lasting candidate connections for future pipelines. And you’ll find the finest options—the ones I’ve loved since our first encounter, and they have only gotten better with time in this recruitment CRM software comparison guide. From finding and tracking potential candidates to managing communication and nurturing relationships, these systems have it all while making your hiring more streamlined and effective.

Show More +
Show Less -

Our Criteria: Here's How We Chose The Best Recruiting CRM Software

Following the SSR HR tech evaluation methodology, I vetted several options and ranked them based on three key factors: effective search, features that help build trust, and the option to enrich profiles.

  • Search capabilities: The smarter the search function is, the better chance you will find the right prospects within your cloud-based talent hub to engage. That's why I really value this feature in my vetting. What's even cooler is that some of the vendors I picked here can even suggest potential profiles based on your specific hiring needs. Basically, these vendors take the hassle out of searching by automating the process for you.
  • Building-trust features. The foundation of any good relationship is trust. For a recruiting CRM platform to be useful, it must help build and maintain trust with potential talent over time. This way, you'll be the first ones they think of when they're considering making a job change. That's why I chose vendors with strong employer branding features, customizable engagement tools, and top-notch data security. This ensures that every interaction with a candidate, whether it's a job landing page, email sequence, or text message, looks and feels not just attractive but trustworthy.
  • Profile-enrichment. Profile enrichment may not be as fancy as the AI-powered features that many providers are pushing. However, I think it's really important to keep your talent pool in good shape (you know how frustrating it is when you find a qualified candidate for a job, only to find out that their contact information is invalid!). Depending on the vendor, profile enrichment can be fully or partly automated to keep your talent database updated regularly.

Using the above factors, I tested the most popular recruiting CRM platforms side by side and in various applications: as a recruiter who uses the software daily for candidate management and engagement, as a candidate who submitted their application for a job before through the CRM and the integrated ATS, and as a hiring manager who oversees the candidate pipelines and recruiting metrics.

For a holistic view of how a candidate relationship management tool is used for real business needs, my colleagues and I asked for takes from multiple software users at companies big and small, including Lisa Pope, Head of People and Culture at Jones Jones LLC, Talent Acquisition Manager Amir Hussain at ACL Digital, and Melissa Varon, RPO Recruiting Manager at KellyOCG. The recruitment CRM software tools that received the best scores are presented in this guide.

Show More +
Show Less -

Compare the Best Recruiting CRM Software

Popularity Score
Best for
Key Differentiator
Pricing
Free Trial
Customers
Users Score
Product Score
4.0
Agencies that want a self-maintaining candidate database
Omnichannel sync auto-links interactions to the right record
From $119/user/month
Get pricing info
Yes
Undisclosed
4.8
4.2
4.1
Small and medium-sized recruiting agencies
Emailing, sales flow, client portal, and invoicing in one place
Starts at $100/mo
Get pricing info
Yes
1,200+ companies
4.7
4.4
4.0
High-volume talent management
Free for startups, top-notch talent sourcing capabilities
Custom Pricing
Get pricing info
Yes
1,200+ companies
4.8
4.6
Phil Strazzulla
HR Tech Expert, Harvard MBA, Software Enthusiast

Need Help? Get Custom Recommendations for Best Recruiting CRM Software

Talk to An Advisor

Detailed Reviews of the Best Recruiting CRM

Spott

Visit Website
Spott
Learn More
Popularity Score
4 / 5
User Score
4.8 / 5
Product Score
4.2 / 5

Why we picked Spott

Spott is a new AI-native recruiting CRM where the database essentially maintains itself. Every call, email, LinkedIn message, and WhatsApp conversation auto-links to the right candidate or company record. A built-in notetaker transcribes calls and feeds data back into profiles, suggesting field updates that recruiters accept or reject. LinkedIn profiles sync automatically, contact details get enriched in the background, and AI suggests structured field updates from every new conversation. For agencies whose CRM data typically goes stale within weeks, that continuous enrichment loop is the core value proposition.

PROS

  • Omnichannel inbox pulls LinkedIn, WhatsApp, email, and VOIP calls into one view, with every interaction auto-linked to the right candidate or company record.
  • Continuous auto-enrichment: LinkedIn data syncs automatically, contact details get enriched, and AI suggests field updates from new conversations — keeping profiles current over time.
  • Built-in notetaker transcribes calls and meetings, then feeds context back into candidate profiles and suggests updates that recruiters accept or reject.
  • Multi-channel outreach campaigns (email, LinkedIn, WhatsApp) run natively inside the CRM with no separate sequencing tool needed.
  • Custom attributes on every record, saveable list and kanban views, and an @mention system to link notes and tasks across candidates, jobs, and colleagues.
  • Client portal lets hiring managers review candidates, leave feedback, and track pipeline status in real time using your agency’s branding.
  • Their In-house migration team can help clients move from their existing CRM within weeks.
  • Semantic search matches candidates by meaning, not just keywords, surfacing non-obvious fits that Boolean queries miss.
  • Unified inbox syncs LinkedIn, WhatsApp, email, and VOIP calls into one view, with every interaction auto-linked to the right candidate record.
  • Built-in notetaker transcribes calls and meetings, then auto-suggests profile updates — keeping your database current without manual data entry.
  • AI matching ranks your full candidate database against job criteria and provides a natural language explanation for each match, so recruiters stay in control.
  • Forward-looking task management: type a task in natural language and Spott auto-links it to the relevant candidate, job, and colleague.
  • Client portal lets hiring managers review shortlisted candidates, leave feedback, and track pipeline status in real time using your agency’s own branding.

CONS

  • Built specifically for recruiting agencies. Corporate talent acquisition and internal HR teams aren’t the target audience.
  • 15+ integrations live and new connectors ship roughly every two weeks, but agencies with deeply embedded third-party workflows may still find gaps.
  • No payroll or invoicing module yet; agencies handling contractor billing will need a separate system.
  • Integration ecosystem is still growing; agencies with deeply embedded third-party workflows may find some connectors on the roadmap rather than live.
  • No payroll or invoicing module yet; agencies handling contractor billing will still need a separate system.

Spott Review

Spott is an AI-native recruiting CRM for staffing and recruiting agencies, backed by Y Combinator (W25) with a $3.2M seed round. The team has been building for about a year and a half and commercially live for roughly 6 months. We demoed the platform and came away particularly impressed by how much it does to keep CRM data clean and current without recruiter effort.

The core CRM value is the omnichannel sync. Calls (VOIP), LinkedIn messages, WhatsApp conversations, and emails all flow into a unified inbox and automatically attach to the correct candidate or company record. A built-in notetaker transcribes meetings and calls, then feeds that context back into profiles — suggesting field updates that recruiters accept or reject. LinkedIn profiles sync and auto-update, and contact enrichment runs in the background. The result is a database that maintains itself over time rather than decaying.

Spott also bundles outreach campaigns (email, LinkedIn, WhatsApp sequences), a client portal for hiring manager collaboration, and AI-powered candidate matching — all natively, with no separate subscriptions. Furthermore, we think Spott can easily become an all-in-one workspace thanks to their open API and MCP support. Agencies can connect automations, analytics, and presentation tools into a single environment without bolting on extra software. That consolidation sets it apart from CRMs like Loxo or Recruiterflow where you'd typically need add-ons for sequencing or enrichment.

Spott Customers

Undisclosed. Notable names include Cornerstone Global Partners, HW Anderson, Alexander Lyons Solutions, Macmillan Davies, and KennedyFitch.

Spott Pricing

Spott publishes pricing on their website, which is uncommon for this category. A 7-day free trial is available with no paywalls. Plans include:

  • Core at $139/user/month (currently $119 promo until May 31): AI-native ATS/CRM, custom objects, email/social/WhatsApp sync, AI search and matching.
  • Pro at $199/user/month (currently $179 promo until May 31): Everything in Core plus automations, multi-channel sequences, data enrichment, and priority support.
  • Enterprise: Custom pricing. Includes everything in Pro plus custom T&Cs, DPA, advanced roles and permissions, flexible invoicing, and a strategic point of contact.

All plans are billed annually with no add-ons or paywalls.

How has Spott Changed Over Time?

Spott evolved from a single-purpose AI report writer for executive search firms into a full ATS and CRM in about a year and a half. They rebuilt their data layer around a vectorized database (enabling semantic search), added a unified communication layer across VOIP, LinkedIn, WhatsApp, and email, and shipped built-in tools for outreach campaigns, analytics, contact enrichment, and CV formatting. Their AI expanded from generating candidate presentations to proactively suggesting field updates, ranking inbound applicants, and filling structured attributes. Backed by a $3.2M seed round, the team ships new features every Friday and is opening a US office in July 2026.

Best For

Recruiting and staffing agencies of any size that need a CRM with continuous auto-enrichment and omnichannel sync, so the database stays current without relying on recruiters to manually log activity.

Spott in action
No items found.

Recruit CRM

Visit Website
Recruit CRM
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.1 / 5
User Score
4.7 / 5
Product Score
4.4 / 5

Why we picked Recruit CRM

Recruit CRM has one of the most extensive CRM features in the space. This platform also impresses us with its frequent feature updates per user request and a transparent pricing structure that includes a timeless free trial.

PROS

  • Excellent CRM features catering to staffing agencies.
  • Personalized email automation and GDPR-compliant profile enrichment feature.
  • Timeless free trial with a fully transparent pricing structure.
  • Unlimited training, multi-language human support, and GPT-4 features in all plans.
  • No extra fees required for basic data migration that includes importing Excel/CSV files with candidates & clients. During the implementation process of this software, the customer service personnel will help transfer your data for free.
  • Great customer service. Their average response time is under two minutes.
  • Powerful Linkedin Integration & Executive/Recruitment Report PDF Generator to save time
  • Tons of resources made available to users including blogs and articles that give you all the information you need to know about how the software works, job description templates to help you get acquainted with all the possible job openings you will be looking to close, and a glossary that gives you the A-Z of recruitment practices.

CONS

  • Email sequencing is only available for the Business plan and above.
  • Service may slow down during peak usage.
  • Doesn’t support in-app SMS messaging.
  • Limited native integrations. Recruit CRM only integrates natively with LinkedIn, Zapier, Logic Melon, some email apps, and Google and Outlook calendars. If you want to run background checks, for example, using Checkr or other background verification platforms, you won’t be able to do that unless you use Zapier’s API extension.
Recruit CRM-dashboard-screenshot

Recruit CRM Review

There are 2 main reasons why I think small and mid-sized staffing agencies should check out this platform: one is its pricing structure. Though slightly higher than Manatal, Recruit CRM is still one of the most affordable options out there. Not to mention, you can use its free trial for as long as you want.

The other reason is the maturity of their products. Having kept an eye on Recruit CRM since I’ve joined SSR in 2022, it amazes me the vendor has always kept agency users in mind when developing its platform. This laser focus has totally paid off and made it one of the go-to options for these users to manage both candidates and clients.

On top of a simple but effective applicant tracking tool, Recruit CRM has a modern CRM system that lets you perform a range of client management tasks, from automating resume formatting to submitting candidates and getting feedback from clients, scheduling appointments, managing invoices, and keeping track of all deals and sales opportunities.

Unlike Manatal, which lacks email scheduling, Recruit CRM lets you craft personalized email sequences (this task is now even easier with the help of GPT tools built-in), determine the specific date and time each goes out, and track how it is performing in real-time.

Unfortunately, this email engagement tool is just a tease on its cheapest plan, as you can only have one sequence with that option.

You should also bear in mind that Recruit CRM doesn’t cover SMS messaging and can be quite slow during peak usage.

Recruit CRM Customers

1,200+ companies, including Avizio, Zeren, and Cooper Coleman.

Recruit CRM Pricing

The cost of Recruit CRM, when billed annually, ranges from $100 to $165 per user per month. A free trial option is available.

How has Recruit CRM Changed Over Time?

Recruit CRM’s recent updates focus on integrating AI into two core areas: candidate sourcing and candidate data structuring.

  • AI candidate matching: Uses a broader set of data points (skills, experience, education, etc.) to surface similar candidates, instead of relying only on keyword search.
  • Improved resume parsing: Now powered by Sovren, extracting more detailed and structured data from resumes, with support for multiple languages.
  • Database enrichment: Parsed data can fill gaps in existing candidate profiles, making the CRM more searchable and useful over time.

Best For

Small and medium-sized staffing agencies to manage client and candidate relationships.

Recruit CRM in action
Reviewer's Rating
9/10

During my time at Maersk, I relied on RecruitCRM almost daily to oversee the recruitment process from start to finish efficiently. This system played a crucial role in monitoring all our interactions with candidates, from initial contact to the final hiring decision. It streamlined communication between departments and offices worldwide, ensuring everyone involved in recruiting was on the same page.

Additionally, it centralized candidate information and conversations, making coordination and follow-up tasks easier throughout our recruitment efforts. Consistently using this tool was vital to maintaining a successful recruitment approach.

What do you like about Recruit CRM?

Efficient Tracking: It keeps all candidate information and statuses at our fingertips.

Customizable Workflows: We can tweak processes to fit exactly how our teams work.

Integration Friendly: It works well with our other HR and operational systems.

Why did your organization buy Recruit CRM, and how long have you used it for?

During my time at Maersk, we implemented a platform called RecruitCRM to address the challenges we faced in managing recruitment efficiently and effectively on a global scale due to our widespread operations and the need to oversee numerous recruitment activities each year. The application enabled us to consolidate candidate information in one place, which helped organize our communications and monitor the overall progress of recruitment processes.

I used the system for more than two years, and it significantly improved our ability to coordinate efforts across different regions, leading to a more seamless and cohesive hiring process. This development greatly enhanced our approach to handling our diverse recruitment needs.

What do you dislike about Recruit CRM?

Learning Curve: It took time for everyone to get the hang of it.

Occasional Glitches: Sometimes, there are minor bugs, especially after updates.

Limited Awareness: The shipping industry uses so many products that many people aren't familiar with this one.

How is Recruit CRM different than their competitors?

RecruitCRM stands out due to its flexibility in accommodating recruitment processes and its ability to integrate seamlessly with other systems or tools. This sets it apart from tools that may lack user-centered features and customization options.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

I recommend ensuring it can scale with your organization and integrate with your existing systems. Ease of use is also crucial—no one wants a tool that’s difficult to learn. Additionally, check how robust their customer support is because you’ll likely need their help at some point.

How has Recruit CRM changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

When I used it, I noticed upgrades that enhanced its user-friendly interface and incorporated new features based on feedback from users. It seems they are quite dedicated to adapting to market needs.

What specific type of user or organization is Recruit CRM very good for?

It's perfect for large, international companies like ours that deal with a high volume of applicants across many different sectors. It's robust enough to handle complex processes and large amounts of data.

What specific type of user or organization would Recruit CRM not be a good fit for?

Small companies or startups might find it too much for their needs. If the recruitment process is straightforward or doesn’t involve many stakeholders, they might be better off with a more concise, less feature-rich system.

Gem

Visit Website
Gem
Learn More
Popularity Score
4 / 5
User Score
4.8 / 5
Product Score
4.6 / 5

Why we picked Gem

Gem’s ability to auto-add and enrich candidate profiles, run outreach campaigns across email, SMS, phone, and InMail, and tap into a database of over 800 million profiles makes it one of the most capable recruiting CRMs we’ve tested. We also like that integrations are not locked behind premium plans, and that Gem continues to expand its platform through smart acquisitions like InterviewPlanner.

PROS

  • Auto-sources profiles from LinkedIn and 20+ sites based on recruiter criteria
  • Email, SMS, phone and LinkedIn InMail sequences with personalization
  • AI rediscovery agent surfaces past candidates from ATS and CRM
  • Unlimited sourcing across 800M+ global profiles, no credit caps
  • Auto-refreshed, enriched candidate profiles
  • 50+ native ATS integrations plus custom API
  • Free for early-stage startups via Gem's Startup Program
  • Gem helps you discover qualified candidates across multiple channels, send personalized messages, visualize your recruitment pipeline, and stay on top of crucial hiring metrics
  • Gem's integration with LinkedIn and various ATS means that all candidate data is stored in a centralized location. Users find this feature extremely useful.
  • According to users, one of Gem's finest features is the ability to create automated drip campaigns to engage with both active and passive candidates

CONS

  • Implementation and data migration can take several weeks
  • No client management tools for staffing agencies
  • No dedicated mobile apps
  • Some users have experienced slow load times and lags while using the application
  • In rare cases, the contact information, such as the email address or phone number of a sourced candidate, might be wrong
  • While Gem currently integrates with LinkedIn, it does not provide the option to automate messages via LinkedIn InMail

Gem Review

Those getting to work on candidate sourcing and outreach are no strangers to Gem, a platform specializing in talent management. I've reviewed more than a few tools in this space in my day, and Gem’s re-engagement feature is perhaps the best I’ve seen.

Tracking down profiles that showed interest at first but then didn’t respond to follow-ups tends to be a headache for almost any TA, so I love the fact that Gem allows users to do just that with a few clicks. Once the targeted audience is selected, it’s also pretty easy to get the sequence ready. I used the pre-built email templates so I didn’t have to start from zero, then added some personalization touches here and there, and wrapped things up by choosing the email address from which my sequence will be sent and scheduling. I can imagine how busy TAs would appreciate this recruitment CRM as they can, in a matter of minutes, revive conversations that have gone cold and bring those candidates back into the active pipeline.

Another thing I like about Gem is its advanced search, particularly through Prospect Search and Gem Prospects. The former lets you curate candidate lists and create talent pools, so your next steps (engaging with these groups) can be more targeted and efficient. Meanwhile, the latter provides you with search tools that work across profiles within your CRM database as well as your connected ATS. With the addition of Gem’s AI rediscovery agent, you can now go even further by searching past applicants and surfacing hidden gems already in your system using natural language prompts instead of Boolean strings.

Compared to competitors like Loxo, Gem supports the same wide array of communication channels: emails, phone calls, and SMS. It also recently added InMail sequences – a feature it lacked during my last review, and now combines these with AI-powered sourcing agents that pull from a proprietary database of more than 800 million profiles. What stood out to me here was the unlimited access. Many sourcing tools restrict search volume or outreach with credits, but with Gem, there are no caps, which is a big win for high-volume recruiting.

However, while Gem now offers monthly subscription options, it still does not have a mobile app. Also, just to keep things clear, their recruiting CRM and ATS are two separate modules, so you’ll need to pay for both if you want to use them. And if you're looking for a recruitment CRM with client management capabilities, my suggestion is to check out different options like Manatal and Recruit CRM, as Gem still does not provide a client portal or features like resume formatting and invoicing.

Gem Customers

1,200+ companies, including Zillow, DoorDash, Anthropic, and Asana.

Gem Pricing

Gem's pricing varies based on client type. For employer organizations, there are three plans: Startups, Growth, and Enterprise, starting at $135/month when billed annually. Staffing firms have a separate pricing structure: Essentials at $99/user/month (annual billing) for up to 3 users, Professional at $149/user/month (annual billing) for up to 10 users, and Enterprise, which requires custom pricing.

How has Gem Changed Over Time?

Gem has expanded from a sourcing and CRM tool into a more integrated recruiting platform, with recent updates focused on improving speed, automation, and workflow coverage across sourcing, CRM, and ATS layers.

Gem AI sourcing performance improvements
  • AI Sourcing Agent surfaces candidate matches faster with background scoring; match quality depends on search inputs
  • Location-radius filtering enables proximity-based searches for hybrid roles
  • AI "not interested" classification reduces manual CRM logging with standardized response reasons
  • Agency workflow management adds restricted-access controls and source tracking within the platform
  • New integrations with Metaview, DocuSign, Dropbox Sign, Juicebox and Wellfound
  • Mobile job access added for on-the-go recruiting workflows

Best For

Startups that qualify for the free program and high-volume recruiting teams that need AI-driven sourcing, transparent ranking, and the option to consolidate into a full ATS plus CRM under one platform.

Gem in action
Reviewer's Rating
9/10

I used Gem daily. Our organization used it to reach out to potential candidates via email. We saw a higher response rate through email compared to LinkedIn. We also used it to store candidates for future positions. Gem allows you to organize candidates by attribute, making it easier to find them later.

What do you like about Gem?

I liked how efficient working with Gem was. Once I identified a candidate I liked, it took only a click to reach out to them. I appreciated the ability to track responses, which made it easier to monitor our response rate. I liked the option to organize candidates based on different attributes for future use, helping me build a pipeline for our most common roles. I also liked that Gem operated as a Chrome extension, making it easy to use alongside LinkedIn.

Why did your organization buy Gem, and how long have you used it for?

My organization purchased Gem to better reach out to candidates for our open positions. Gem allowed us to contact potential candidates via email rather than messaging them on LinkedIn. This could be done with the click of a button.

Gem even provided us with multiple email addresses for certain candidates. It reduced our time contacting candidates from about one minute to as little as ten seconds, which adds up over time. We also found that we received a better response rate when reaching out to candidates through email compared to LinkedIn.

What do you dislike about Gem?

I disliked how glitchy the software was at times. Sometimes, I would click on the application, and it would take a few tries to open. I disliked the user interface, as it took some time to get used to navigating around Gem. I think Gem has room for improvement in the AI space. It would be helpful to have additional customization options for messaging based on a candidate's profile.

How is Gem different than their competitors?

I have not used other tools similar to Gem.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

People should focus on their employee population and what communication method they respond to best. I find that different populations respond differently to email compared to LinkedIn.

How has Gem changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

Gem hasn't made many changes over time to adapt to user needs. It has become less glitchy over time.

What specific type of user or organization is Gem very good for?

Gem works great for recruiting organizations.

What specific type of user or organization would Gem not be a good fit for?

Gem would not be a good fit for organizations that recruit employees who do not have an online presence.

Humanly

Visit Website
Humanly
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.2 / 5
User Score
4.1 / 5
Product Score
4.5 / 5

Why we picked Humanly

For any team looking to keep a tight, organized grip on talent outreach and nurturing, I highly recommend Humanly. From the dynamic filtering and candidate status labels to the timeline view and re-engagement campaigns, the platform amazed me with its nuanced approach to candidate relationship management.

PROS

  • Smart candidate calibration and filtering across multiple sources
  • Detailed candidate status labels for nuanced pipeline visibility
  • Built-in follow-up reminders for long-term candidate nurturing
  • Humanly leverages a huge database of candidates to present you with talent from all corners of the globe. You can also source new ones through their Chrome extension while browsing sites like LinkedIn and GitHub.
  • The Humanly tool integrates with hundreds of ATSs, providing an upgrade to your sourcing that won’t require you to switch tools.
  • Generative AI is cleverly implemented for messaging candidates, automating campaigns, and ranking candidates at various stages of the hiring funnel, yet a human can step in and take over at any time.
  • Their reporting module is among the cleanest and most in-depth we’ve seen for this kind of tool.

CONS

  • No free plan or trial available
  • Lacks core ATS features like job posting, career sites and resume parsing
  • Opaque pricing, less suited for small businesses
  • Since it’s a tool that was relaunched after a company acquisition, there might be some changes in the near future that could impact your workflows.
  • The price point might be a bit steep for smaller teams, but they do offer custom prices based on the functionality you need and the number of users.

Humanly Review

Humanly’s CRM functionality offers a smart, organized approach to keeping track of each candidate interaction and tailoring outreach based on engagement history.

When it comes to candidate calibration and filtering, there was clearly a lot of care put into the development of this duo. During testing, I could pull passive candidates I’ve gathered with Humanly’s sourcing extension, those actively applying before, potential referrals, and existing contacts in the integrated ATS. Then apply personalized ranking to find each role’s top matches. Bye for good, the days of sifting through multiple sources!

Another feature I found especially useful was the Candidate Status Labels, which offer a more nuanced view of each candidate’s status than the usual “active” or “inactive” buckets. For example, a “Sourced” status indicates that a candidate profile is still being processed, while “Reached” provides details on why outreach was stopped—an efficient way to gauge the next steps.

And, recruiters—you’ve got to check out the Saved for Later option on each candidate’s card. This feature allows you to set follow-up reminders (one week, one month, three months, etc.). Imagine when a candidate is interested in a role but needs more time before moving forward, and you’ve got this tool in your hand. Simply lifesaving, isn’t it?

Humanly recruitment CRM save for later option

On par with some household names like SmartRecruiters and Recruiterflow, Humanly let me filter candidates who hadn’t responded to past outreach efforts and set up new messaging campaigns to follow up.

Yet, with that smart sourcing and engagement capability comes some compromises in terms of pricing. Although specific pricing is custom, the estimations I've gotten could be steep for some small businesses.

I was also hoping for a more flexible pricing structure from the recruitment CRM software. While Humanly does offer a monthly billing option, it neither offers a free plan nor a free trial.

Feature-wise, Humanly currently doesn’t support some core ATS functionalities, such as job posting, resume parsing, and career sites. So, if these features are must-haves for you, look for our top ATS choices instead.

Humanly Customers

1,000+ companies, including TheKey, Aya Healthcare, and Noom.

Humanly Pricing

Humanly’s pricing details are not publicly available.

How has Humanly Changed Over Time?

Humanly's most notable recent update is the introduction of a video-based AI interviewer with a realistic avatar, moving beyond text and voice-only screening. The goal is to generate more structured candidate responses that feed consistently into downstream screening workflows. This reflects a broader industry shift toward treating early-stage conversations as a data source rather than relying on resumes alone. That said, the approach still requires recruiter oversight to interpret outputs and maintain an appropriate candidate experience.

Best For

Companies seeking a powerful addition to their ATS to enhance outreach and strengthen the recruitment pipeline.

Humanly in action
No items found.

SmartRecruiters

Visit Website
SmartRecruiters
Learn More
Popularity Score
4 / 5
User Score
4.2 / 5
Product Score
4 / 5

Why we picked SmartRecruiters

Targeted at mid-sized and large enterprises, SmartRecruiters offers a highly configurable CRM solution that lets you form talent communities, craft automated engagement campaigns, and track their performance in real-time.

PROS

  • Forms talent communities by specific hiring needs, skill sets, or shared traits.
  • Search candidates by phone number, partial email address, and more.
  • Branded sign-up pages for talent communities that allow self-sign-up without job applications.
  • Regular updates with new or enhanced features.
  • SmartRecruiters has a built-in candidate assessment and skill testing module that allows you to predict cultural fit, future performance and retention, without needing to integrate third-party solutions. 
  • SmartRecruiters provides features for offer management. You can create offer letter templates, share them with successful applicants, and collect their e-signatures from any device using SmartRecruiters’ DocuSign integration.
  • Speaking of integrations, SmartRecruiters has pre-built integrations with over 500 HR solutions and job boards. You can also ask SmartRecruiters’ team to build additional integrations for you if it doesn’t integrate with products in your tech stack.

CONS

  • Marketed as an add-on for SmartRecruit ATS.
  • Enriching profiles requires using partner service.
  • Undisclosed pricing. No free trial is available.
  • SmartRecruiters’ pricing isn’t transparent. Interested users have to go through the sales team to receive a quote. Users are also not able to create trial accounts on their own. 
  • Users have reported a steep learning curve and that the UI takes time to get used to. Some users have also reported that the system can be slow and glitches at times.
  • The reporting feature doesn’t always retrieve data accurately. Some users have also complained that report customizations and KPI tracking capabilities are limited.
  • Candidate filtering is quite limited. As it stands, only basic options such as degree, location, gender etc are provided.
SmartRecruiters-recruiting-crm-software-dashboard

SmartRecruiters Review

I briefly introduced SmartRecruiters as a highly configurable CRM solution earlier, and here is what I mean by that. First, this platform performed well across all my testing devices: laptop, tablet, and phone— both when I logged in as a recruiter user and as a candidate. Second, from CRM and ATS to onboarding and chatbot, it can single-handedly bundle all these tools under one hub, or, if you prefer, you can pick and choose just what you want.

However, what impressed me most about this recruitment CRM is its Campaign, which lets you narrow down your talent search even further when you set up a campaign. For instance, you can choose to target only people you've contacted within your Contract Driver segment who live within 50 miles of New York and who confirmed in your screening question that they have a driver's license. Then, in the sequence section, you can set up rules to only send the next message X days after the last message was opened or clicked on.

SmartRecruiters has also done a good job with its search functionality. From keywords to Boolean, advanced search, and even custom filters, I haven’t found anything its competitors do that this CRM doesn’t.

But what a bummer! Such a capable option doesn't have an automatic candidate enrichment feature built in. Additionally, due to its enterprise-focused nature, SmartRecruiters doesn't offer a free trial, and its prices are somewhat steep compared to its peers.

SmartRecruiters Customers

4,000+ companies, including VISA, Nine, and Devoteam.

SmartRecruiters Pricing

SmartRecruiters pricing starts at $14,995.

How has SmartRecruiters Changed Over Time?

Best For

Mid-sized and large enterprises worldwide.

SmartRecruiters in action
Reviewer's Rating
7/10

As an ATS solution to post, compile, review, and track candidates. I use it for reporting out time to fill, critical needs, and status updates in real-time. I use the data to understand where we are getting our most candidates, which postings are performing better than others, and keep the pipeline of candidates open.

I was able to pass off the administrative access to the operations manager who wasn't technology-savvy, and even he was able to navigate it without issue. It solved the manual process that the client had before using the platform.

What do you like about SmartRecruiters?

It eliminates the manual, administrative process of posting for positions. As the company grows, it becomes time-intensive to hire multiple positions at the same time. SmartRecruiters is a platform that enables me to work smarter, not harder.

As a consultant, you know that you are there for a limited engagement and that the solutions that you find will need to be transferred to clients. That means that the software and the solution need to be easy to navigate and understand, which SR was.

I've worked with SmartRecruiters for years and have never had an issue with passing it off to the client.

Why did your organization buy SmartRecruiters, and how long have you used it for?

I have used SmartRecruiters off and on for the past 10 years as an ATS solution for small and medium-sized businesses (both professionally and as a consultant). Most recently, I worked with a client who was receiving resumes manually, posting on job boards individually, and tracking in an Excel spreadsheet.

The company was growing and it was a bit of an unnecessary administrative burden. When I came on board, I immediately recognized the need for a platform, but they thought it was out of their reach. We reviewed a variety of vendors and settled on SmartRecruiters for their ATS solution.

What do you dislike about SmartRecruiters?

It doesn't make financial sense for smaller clients. I would like to see a more basic platform that is available for those types of clients, so they can still benefit from the platform, but on a budget.

There are also some integration limitations which I would like to see more of. They integrate with the major players, but not so much the newer, smaller HRIS. I'd like a bit more customization and branding capabilities.

How is SmartRecruiters different than their competitors?

It is pricier than other platforms (think $10k+). It has been in the field for a long time and you benefit from that type of market knowledge. They have the tools and processes that they have learned from over the years which other competitors may not have.

I prefer SmartRecruiters for larger companies, just not so much for smaller and mid-sized businesses due to cost.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

Your budget! It is an enterprise system, so you need to make sure it is within your budget. You need to understand your hiring volume and take that into consideration. If you aren't hiring that much, is it worth the spend?

How has SmartRecruiters changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

SmartRecruiters has gotten better. I've used SmartRecruiters for a variety of clients and they take your feedback seriously. I've seen the platform grow and evolve.

What specific type of user or organization is SmartRecruiters very good for?

SmartRecruiters is better for larger, more enterprise-level organizations.

What specific type of user or organization would SmartRecruiters not be a good fit for?

SmartRecruiters may be too expensive for small and medium-sized businesses (especially those with a low volume of positions).

Bullhorn

Visit Website
Bullhorn
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.4 / 5
User Score
3.9 / 5
Product Score
4.3 / 5

Why we picked Bullhorn

Bullhorn has long been on my recommendation list for enterprises in the staffing and recruiting industry. Its smart engagement automation features are adept at increasing candidate conversion rates within the users' existing database.

PROS

  • Effective candidate re-engagement driving more placements from existing ATS data
  • Scheduled SMS and email messaging for timely outreach
  • Fast Find, Boolean and Saved Searches for quick and advanced profile retrieval
  • SourceBreaker provides productive automation for candidate search and business development.
  • End-to-end solution: ATS, interview scheduling, talent engagements, onboarding, and invoicing.
  • Easy implementation and transition from existing ATS.
  • 40+ native VMS integrations.

CONS

  • High pricing, estimated at $25,000 for a team of 1,200
  • Steep learning curve with an unintuitive UI
  • No native profile enrichment, relies on Bullhorn partner marketplace
  • Limited mobile app functionality
  • The UI is not very user-friendly, and the system can be slow at times.
  • Customer support service isn’t very responsive.
Bullhorn-recruiting-CRM-software-dashboard

Bullhorn Review

I actually met Bullhorn when I still worked in the staffing space a few years back and had a great experience with this tool. Unlike Loxo and Gem, Bullhorn doesn't have the ability to find new candidates, but it’s a robust recruiting solution made for staffing agencies and is extremely helpful when you have a huge candidate database in your ATS to utilize.

With Bullhorn, you can set up rules, like reaching out to profiles for whom you haven't added a new note for 3 months. The system will then auto-contact these candidates with a personalized campaign that you design. Plus, when you create a campaign in Bullhorn, the timing will be adjusted to the recipient's time zone to ensure your messages hit their inbox right when they're most likely to be seen and appreciated. Every staffing recruiter I know always prioritizes searching their existing talent database before anything else, as this is a smart way to utilize resources and has remained their top source of hires for years. So, seeing Bullhorn double down on optimizing this essential aspect is genuinely impressive.

To test this CRM further, I tried its search tools. Fast Find let me find a candidate without having to enter their full name. Advanced Search understood Boolean search terms and was fast at producing search results. There are also Saved Searches to ensure TAs don’t duplicate efforts.

However, I’m quite disappointed that Bullhorn does not have a native feature to enrich talent profiles. You either have to reach out to candidates as a workaround, or purchase enrichment tools like CandidateIQ by Vettd from Bullhorn’s partner marketplace.

The platform’s mobile app was also less intuitive than I had hoped. I can barely do anything beyond the basics, like viewing tasks and companies. All the text I added to a note was turned into lowercase. Moreover, the app didn’t let me see comments on candidate profiles or do any kind of reporting or analytics.

Bullhorn Customers

10,000+ companies, including ManpowerGroup, Robert Half, and Adecco.

Bullhorn Pricing

Bullhorn pricing has not been disclosed, yet according to our research, it tends to be on the higher end of the market.

How has Bullhorn Changed Over Time?

Best For

Staffing and recruiting firms that manage a large talent pool and seek to optimize their re-engagement strategies efficiently.

Bullhorn in action
Reviewer's Rating
7/10

I use Bullhorn strictly as a time management tool, but others within the organization use it as an ATS for recruiting. It also has an onboarding integration tool that allows you to create forms needed for onboarding, house the forms when completed by the candidate, and send reminders to candidates if they forget to fill out a necessary form. There are also metric reporting capabilities for time management, applicant tracking, and post-offer once they are in the onboarding phase. For high-volume agency staffing firms, it keeps you organized. For example, if you are hiring for a client that has multiple shifts, you can differentiate this in Bullhorn. You can also run reports to see how many openings you fill per requisition and how many open positions are left.

What do you like about Bullhorn?

The compact feature of storing all data in one place. The email integration tool is great. There never seemed to be any disruptions with notifications and/or emails being sent either in bulk or to an individual.

Why did your organization buy Bullhorn, and how long have you used it for?

As a staffing agency, we used Bullhorn as an ATS as well as a time management tool. We have many contingent staff workers and wanted to keep them separate from our HRIS that housed all of our full-time employees. I have used it for a couple of years solely as a time management tool. It was very easy to use for submitting and approving time for others. It also sent weekly reminders to managers to approve their contingent employees' time.

What do you dislike about Bullhorn?

It's a slower system compared to others. Customer service or live chat isn't the best, as getting a response takes some time. I wish the reports for time management were more detailed and broke down hours worked, hourly rate, and the ability to view paystubs to help employees with questions.

How is Bullhorn different than their competitors?

RecruiterFlow is very similar from an ATS and onboarding perspective, but it does not have a time management tool to my knowledge like Bullhorn does. Bullhorn is also a bit more expensive than RecruiterFlow, but you get an additional feature, so it's worth it in the end.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

What am I using this for? Do I need it for more than just an ATS? If the answer is yes, then Bullhorn is worth it. If I do use it as an ATS, is it for high volume? If so, then Bullhorn will keep you organized.

How has Bullhorn changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

I haven't noticed any significant changes in the couple of years that I have used it.

What specific type of user or organization is Bullhorn very good for?

Staffing agencies only! For a company that does direct hiring, Bullhorn is not worth investing in. This is best for managing contract employees.

What specific type of user or organization would Bullhorn not be a good fit for?

Large direct hire companies would not find Bullhorn useful, unless they are looking to keep contingent staff separate from their full-time employees. At that point, they could just get the basic package, which is half the price of the corporate package.

Manatal

Visit Website
Manatal
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.2 / 5
User Score
4.7 / 5
Product Score
4.2 / 5

Why we picked Manatal

Manatal is widely known for its generosity in terms of features: applicant tracking, AI recommendations, candidate profile enrichment, and a recruiting CRM—all at a pretty low price.

PROS

  • Robust applicant tracking capabilities and auto candidate profile enrichment.
  • Services start at $15/month, with a free trial and flexible payment options.
  • Multilingual and mobile-optimized interface.
  • Highly accurate search functionality.
  • Suitable for both corporations and agencies.
  • Manatal is quite affordable and offers a 15-day free trial for users to test it out before making commitments.
  • Manatal is fairly easy to use. It features drag-and-drop enabled pipelines for candidate organization.
  • Manatal’s AI-based recommendations feature can save hiring managers quite a bit of time. It’s able to scan job descriptions then search a users talent pool and bring up candidates most suited for the job.

CONS

  • Integrations rely on Zapier. Their API is available only to top-tier subscribers.
  • The extension relies solely on LinkedIn to source profiles.
  • No email scheduling capability.
  • Only custom plan users have access to phone support.
  • The AI recommendations feature works best with resumes that are in English, and doesn’t work as accurately with other languages according to several users’ feedback. Several users have also complained about Manatal’s interface only being available in English and that career pages cannot be published in languages other than English and Spanish. 
  • Manatal doesn’t offer a free plan. We mention this as a con as several SMB-geared ATSs do offer a free-forever verison, and that puts Manatal slightly behind competition. 
  • Manatal doesn’t offer prebuilt integration modules. They do have an open API that allows users to plug in third-party products and custom tools, but that required a bit more time and technical knowledge to accomplish. It’s also worth mentioning that only Custom plan customers can access Manatal’s API and Zapier integration. Customers on the Professional and Enterprise plan cannot.
  • Users can search for candidates via Boolean Search or Advanced Search, but cannot combine the two search methods together. E.g users cannot use the Boolean search operators (AND, OR and NOT) within Manatal’s Advanced Search tab.
Manatal-recruiting-CRM-software-dashboard

Manatal Review

I think Manatal should be proud of its candidate enrichment functionality. It can run on autopilot if you let it, and more importantly, it is highly accurate. By leveraging existing profile information as parameters, this platform's AI can trace down matching social media accounts, then dig for any missing intel and fill it into the system for you. Coincidences do happen, so I’m glad the AI is programmed to only enrich a profile when it’s at least 70% confident the found social media account is the right one.

Mantal’s search features are also pretty cool. There's a Quick Search for basic things like finding a candidate by their name. If you need something more specific, like candidates with certain skills, languages, and experience, the Advanced Search is where it's at. This feature ranks each result based on how close it matches what you're looking for, so you get the most relevant profiles in a matter of seconds.

Manatal has done an okay job with engagement features. It offers SMS and emails, and the mass option is also included. However, there are some inconveniences. One issue is that there’s no email campaign scheduling I can find when testing this tool, which can be a real hassle for those working with talent in different time zones.

Additionally, beyond job boards, Manatal has just 7 native HRMS integration options: Sprout, Humaans, HiBob, Omni HR, WorkDigital, Melioris, and BambooHR—a very humble number compared to other CRM tools I’ve picked in this guide.

Manatal Customers

Manatal is used by 10,000+ organizations, including Adecco, Decathlon, and Tesco.

Manatal Pricing

Manatal pricing starts at $15 per user per month when billed annually. A 14-day free trial is available, and no credit card information is required.

How has Manatal Changed Over Time?

Best For

Budget-minded, small-to-midsized recruitment teams and staffing agencies.

Manatal in action
Reviewer's Rating
7/10

I used Manatal for creating webpages to attract candidates, posting jobs to multiple job boards and social media platforms from one location, and tracking candidates through the screening process. It facilitated communication and scheduling for team members involved in hiring, ensuring everyone was informed and coordinated. The analytics and reports feature was instrumental in evaluating hiring timelines and identifying the most effective sources for candidates. This functionality allowed us to refine our recruitment strategy and make informed decisions on where to invest in promoting positions.

What do you like about Manatal?

The coordination of the hiring process among team members was significantly improved, reducing miscommunications and the hassle of scheduling. Manatal's candidate tracking and database features prevented delays in the recruitment stages and helped us avoid losing good candidates to human error.

The ability to create company showcase web pages was invaluable in attracting sought-after candidates for challenging positions. Additionally, the access to detailed reports and data supported our decision-making with evidence, optimizing our recruitment budget and strategies.

Why did your organization buy Manatal, and how long have you used it for?

We adopted Manatal to address challenges in managing a high volume of recruiting, especially for hard-to-fill positions with lengthy recruitment processes. We found it difficult to efficiently find the right candidates, and the coordination of the recruitment process was hard, resulting in missed tasks and delays. Additionally, we sought a better way to showcase our company as an attractive place to work, as traditional job postings were insufficient. We experienced loss of good candidates due to protracted processes or confusion over contact points and screening stages. Manatal offered a solution to better coordinate hiring efforts, track candidate progress, and enhance our attractiveness to potential applicants. I personally have used it for about a year.

What do you dislike about Manatal?

Some team members found the interface unintuitive, with key features like email templates being hard to locate. The lack of a standalone mobile app initially was a limitation (not anymore), and certain functionalities, such as self-scheduling for candidates and enhancing the focus on candidate relationship management, needed further development for a better candidate experience.

How is Manatal different than their competitors?

Manatal holds its ground as a competitive tool in the recruitment software market, offering a comprehensive set of features. However, it required a steeper learning curve compared to other tools I have used, although it also provided superior customer service, which added value to our experience.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

Prospective buyers should weigh the cost against their specific needs. If your organization does not engage in frequent hiring or if the existing team efficiently manages recruitment, this tool might exceed your requirements. However, for businesses with high recruitment volumes and a collaborative hiring process, Manatal could streamline operations, enhance your company's appeal to candidates, and potentially lead to more successful hires.

How has Manatal changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

Manatal has made significant improvements, including the development of a mobile app and enhancements to its user interface to be more intuitive. The dashboard has been upgraded for easier navigation, reflecting the company's commitment to evolving in line with user feedback.

What specific type of user or organization is Manatal very good for?

Manatal is ideally suited for small to medium-sized companies engaged in frequent hiring. It is particularly beneficial for organizations with collaborative hiring processes and those needing to attract high-demand candidates through compelling career pages.

What specific type of user or organization would Manatal not be a good fit for?

For small businesses with minimal hiring needs, Manatal may not be cost-effective due to underutilization of its features. Conversely, very large companies requiring extensive customization and complex recruitment workflows might find Manatal's capabilities too basic for their needs.

Loxo

Visit Website
Loxo
Learn More
Popularity Score
4 / 5
User Score
4.6 / 5
Product Score
4 / 5

Why we picked Loxo

Loxo stands out due to its impressive automation capabilities and multi-channel engagement options. Plus, the platform has just added a free plan, so you can give it a go before deciding to go premium.

PROS

  • Automated outreach campaigns triggered by candidate pipeline stage
  • Multi-channel engagement via email, SMS, calls and InMail
  • Free plan with unlimited users and jobs
  • Loxo Connect for direct candidate contact information
  • Periodic automatic candidate data enrichment
  • In-app GPT for personalized engagement content and campaigns
  • Excellent customer service with a strong record of fast response times.
  • User-friendly resume parsing.
  • Friendly and visually appealing user interface.
  • Offers a convenient Chrome extension.
  • Allows client involvement in projects with direct interaction.
  • Regularly releases new product updates.
  • Includes a free plan.

CONS

  • No Android app; iOS app lacks job orders and recruiter notes
  • Complex pricing with numerous add-ons
  • Candidate engagement tools excluded from free plan
  • Loxo Connect Credits reset monthly with no rollover
  • Slightly higher pricing compared to similar tools.
  • Lack of an option to auto-anonymize resumes for blind screening.
  • Reporting is not particularly useful with certain useful metrics not tracked.
  • No Android app. Limited features and occasional performance issues on the iOS app.

Loxo-recruiting-crm-software-dashboard

Loxo Review

If you’re eyeing a recruitment CRM with seamless automation and robust multi-channel outreach, I highly recommend you look into Loxo. This platform offers emails, texts, calls, and inMails. It recently also added some cool GPT tools to assist recruiters with their engagement work.

Diving deeper into its automation features, auto-add is something I have only seen in Loxo and nowhere else yet. This unique feature enables users to attach an outreach campaign to not just each job but also each job stage independently. During my tech test, it let me have one for my 'Shortlist' job stage and another for my 'Screening' one. And as I added myself as a candidate to this pipeline, I received tailored messages as my profile progressed through these stages.

Fellow automation enthusiasts will easily like Loxo’s auto-refreshing database as much as I do. It’s such a sassy tool that leverages the system’s proprietary search engine and AI to continually enrich candidate profiles with the latest info they can find online, be it job changes, relocations, new contact details, or anything in between.

Alternatively, you can use Loxo Connect to get prospective talent’s contact info. I have to warn you, though, that this tool comes with a fee and your paid credits reset at the end of each month. In other words, all your unused credits in a month will not be rolled over to the next.

I wouldn’t go for this recruitment CRM if my business were on a budget, as Loxo’s free plan doesn't include engagement elements like email sequences, phone calls, SMS texting, and the Outreach GPT. You'll need to upgrade to one of the two most expensive plans to get access to these tools.

Another downside to Loxo is that there’s no mobile app for Android users, and its iOS app is not very user-friendly and lacks certain features like job orders and recruiter notes.

Loxo Customers

13,000+ companies, including Randstad, Cigna, and Lockton.

Loxo Pricing

Loxo offers a free-forever plan and 3 premium plans starting at $199 per user per month. Potential customers can take advantage of a 7-day free trial before committing to a paid subscription.

How has Loxo Changed Over Time?

Best For

Mid-to-large recruitment agencies and in-house recruitment teams looking to automate their candidate engagement process and maintain an up-to-date database.

Loxo in action
Reviewer's Rating
7/10

We used Loxo when we started retained searches. It is also used by our firm as a CRM for opportunistic candidates and searches. It is used from candidate sourcing through candidate hire and for tracking everything in between. Our clients use it to view candidate profiles and status as well. The system is used by everyone in the company on a daily basis. The system is regularly running automated campaigns for candidate outreach.

What do you like about Loxo?
  • User interface - great looking and intuitive user interface.
  • User experience - easy to move candidates through job status and get candidates into the system from sources like LinkedIn.
  • Automated outreach - simple to use automated campaigns that allow you to do bulk outreach with one click.
Why did your organization buy Loxo, and how long have you used it for?

We originally purchased Loxo due to the user interface and AI/Sourcing functionality. Tools we used in the past were archaic and lacked a good user experience. Loxo offers integrations with LinkedIn and a Sourcing function that wow'd us during the demo. We have been using Loxo for approximately 4 months.

What do you dislike about Loxo?
  • The CRM is lacking and seems to operate separately from the ATS.
  • The automated campaigns are great but the emails do not look as clean/polished as if they came straight from Outlook or GSuite.
  • AI Sourcing looks great in the demo but is quite buggy during regular use.
How is Loxo different than their competitors?

Simple, streamlined, easy to navigate. Loxo makes it easy to do the basics in recruiting.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

How big is your team and what type of tool/reporting do you need to scale? - Loxo is good for the basics but the more complex/sophisticated your operation is, the more likely Loxo is not the right solution for you.

Search vs. Corporate - Loxo seems like it would be better for corporate users vs. agency recruiters.

How has Loxo changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

Loxo seems to regularly update the solution and add new features. During the short 4 months, they have already added a ChatGPT functionality.

What specific type of user or organization is Loxo very good for?

Loxo is a good solution for start-ups or small agencies that do not have plans to scale and keep their processes simple.

What specific type of user or organization would Loxo not be a good fit for?

Loxo is not great for large agencies that offer multiple types of search solutions as the reporting functionality is not built for it.

JobAdder

Visit Website
JobAdder
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.1 / 5
User Score
4.5 / 5
Product Score
4.4 / 5

Why we picked JobAdder

JobAdder truly knows how to make it easy to engage with candidates from various channels. The CRM also impressed me with its flexible pricing options, customizable workflows, and a long list of integration partners.

PROS

  • Multiple communication channels (email, SMS, WhatsApp) for candidate engagement.
  • Automated candidate data enrichment.
  • Good integration partners (150+ options to date).
  • Discounts are available for not-for-profit businesses and charities.
  • Easy to use and easy data migration.
  • Client portal for a clear communication flow between agencies and clients.
  • Email, SMS, and WhatsApp for talent engagement.
  • In-depth onboarding and in-platform training.
  • Monthly payments. No lock-in contracts and no penalty fees to switch either.
  • 150+ integration partners.
  • Native iOS and Android apps.

CONS

  • Price has gone up considerably over the past 2 years.
  • Customer support can be slow and refer users to self-help sections.
  • UI can be clunky at times.
  • No option to merge deals or contacts.
  • No free trial.
  • Limited administrative power to resolve issues.
JobAdder-recruiting-CRM-software-dashboard

JobAdder Review

In my testing, JobAdder performed just as well as Recruit CRM, Manatal, and Bullhorn when it comes to candidate engagement tools. I can use email, SMS, or even WhatsApp to reach talent through this platform. Plus, there's a bulk messaging option that allows me to send messages to up to 500 profiles at once. I tried bugging 50 of my contacts to see how this feature goes. There were just a few steps to take, and the emails were sent out almost instantly.

Like Bullhorn, I can view my candidates from my integrated ATS (BambooHR was the one I used at the time) right in JobAdder. I can also sort them based on their skills, ratings, lookalikes, and a handful more. What sets this recruitment CRM apart from others I’ve reviewed, though, is its deep integration with SEEK Talent Search Connect. Given that over twelve million candidates on SEEK are available to tap into right within JobAdder, not just the ones already in the ATS,  thanks to this integration, this can’t be a greener flag, especially for teams looking for talent in Australia and Asia.

Also, thanks to this integration, the candidate data enrichment feature gets a boost: Not only does it automatically keep track of activities, notes, and documents, but it also fills in the latest details it finds from SEEK for you.

Unfortunately, there's been a lot of grumbling about how the prices on this platform keep going up. On another note, an awful number of JobAdder users I talked to and myself aren’t happy with the support we’ve been offered. They tend to be slow to respond and often just redirect users to self-help resources.

JobAdder Customers

1,000+ companies, including Firefish, West Recruitment, and MAYDAY.

JobAdder Pricing

JobAdder’s CRM offers customized pricing.

How has JobAdder Changed Over Time?

Best For

Recruitment agencies in the UK and Australia.

JobAdder in action
Reviewer's Rating
7/10

We used JobAdder for full-cycle recruitment every day. The platform was the main source to complete our role as Recruitment Consultants. From posting our adverts to our careers site and job boards to managing applications, moving through the necessary stages, and building talent pools.

JobAdder is a great cloud-based CRM tool as the dashboard allows you to quickly see the progress on each open role and what actions you need to prioritize. The key workflows were the ability to integrate with job boards and our careers page. The second was the ability to send a message to multiple candidates at the click of a button. This was great for when we had an urgent role to fill or news to share with our database. This also applies to clients; having a client database in one place allows effective communication and relationship building.

What do you like about JobAdder?
  1. It enables efficiency as jobs can easily be managed in one place and it helps prioritize tasks effectively.
  2. Having the candidate database in one place allows for roles to be filled quickly, which provides good service for clients.
  3. Being able to see all of my colleagues' notes in one place fosters a good working culture as you are more inclined to work as a team.
Why did your organization buy JobAdder, and how long have you used it for?

I used JobAdder in a previous recruitment role. JobAdder was purchased because the agency required a solution that held the candidate database in one place for all employees to view resumes, notes, current placements, and any other necessary information to ensure a smooth and efficient process.

It was essential for all staff to have access to an abundance of candidates. It was great for the organization to avoid contacting candidates who were already working for one of our clients.

We had salary expectations and availability all in one place. It saved consultants time on sourcing and phone screens. Additionally, it created a much better culture as consultants would split placement fees since we could track who brought the candidate on originally.

What do you dislike about JobAdder?
  1. It is more suitable for single placements rather than volume placements; it would be better to be able to add a bulk list of candidates to a job.
  2. Often if you need support, you are referred to a self-help section, which is time-consuming when you need a quick fix.
  3. It is frustrating that 'contacts' and 'candidates' are separate profiles, often resulting in entering the information twice.
How is JobAdder different than their competitors?

I have also used SuccessFactors (SAP) and find JobAdder a much easier platform as the layout is user-friendly and not overly complicated.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

Consider the types of placements you are looking to fill. If you fill a lot of volume roles, make sure you check the efficiency in the demo. Also, consider the pricing as it is per user and can add up.

How has JobAdder changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

JobAdder is good at making big improvements, and the integration with ChatGPT and AI tools is great, but they need to work on smaller things such as the duplicate data entry for candidate profiles.

What specific type of user or organization is JobAdder very good for?

Recruitment Agencies and companies that hire a lot will find JobAdder very useful.

What specific type of user or organization would JobAdder not be a good fit for?

JobAdder would not be beneficial for a company that isn't solely focused on hiring.

Hellora

Visit Website
Hellora
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.1 / 5
User Score
4.5 / 5
Product Score
4.3 / 5

Why we picked Hellora

Hellora evolved from employee referral software into a recruiting CRM purpose-built for U.S. healthcare hiring. We found that narrow focus makes their AI more compelling than generic implementations, as it's applied to solving healthcare-specific recruiting challenges through explainable candidate matching, continuous profile enrichment, and personalized outreach for clinicians already in an organization's ATS.

PROS

  • Purpose-built for U.S. healthcare hiring with AI trained on clinical roles, licenses and workflows
  • Semantic search identifies qualified candidates in ATS databases without keyword matching
  • Continuously updates candidate profiles using healthcare licensing data
  • Sends outreach directly from recruiters' Outlook and Gmail inboxes
  • Centralized email and SMS inbox with AI-drafted candidate messaging
  • Built-in employee referral and hiring event management
  • Fully text-based system requires no app downloads, facilitating quick and easy referrals.
  • Automated tracking and eligibility checks reduce administrative workload.
  • Integration with over 30 ATS and HRIS platforms ensures seamless data flow.
  • AI assistant Eve enhances referral accuracy and employee engagement.

CONS

  • Limited to U.S. healthcare hiring, not suited for multi-industry or international organizations
  • Engagement history and conversation intelligence still maturing
  • No native interview scheduling or calendar integrations
  • Currently supports only U.S.-based organizations.
  • Primarily designed for large enterprises with 2,000+ employees, which may not suit smaller organizations.

Hellora Review

Hellora takes a deliberately narrow approach to recruiting CRM, focusing almost entirely on U.S. healthcare talent engagement rather than trying to serve every industry. Throughout our demo, that specialization was evident in nearly every workflow.

Hellora recruiting CRM software

The platform's strongest capability is candidate rediscovery. Instead of relying on keyword searches and filters, recruiters can search using natural language while the AI evaluates resumes, licenses, previous applications, referrals, hiring event participation, and other structured and unstructured candidate data. We also liked that the platform explains why each candidate is a match instead of simply assigning a score, giving recruiters the context they need to validate recommendations rather than treating AI results as a black box.

Hellora handles the profile enrichment using public licensing databases and updates from its healthcare network (with candidate permission), helping you keep your talent databases more current. Once suitable candidates are identified, recruiters can launch AI-assisted email and SMS campaigns with personalized messaging that remains fully editable before being sent.

In terms of communication, we found value in the platform's ability to facilitate outreach via recruiters’ existing Outlook and Gmail accounts. By avoiding secondary domains, the CRM makes the engagement more personalized.

We also found that the platform is most differentiated during candidate sourcing and re-engagement. Beyond that, the CRM is still evolving. For example, native interview scheduling isn't available yet, candidate profiles don't currently consolidate interactions such as phone calls and Zoom meetings, and much of the relationship management centers on outreach campaigns rather than maintaining a richer, long-term engagement history. The product team shared that several of these capabilities are already on the roadmap.

Ultimately, healthcare providers looking to reactivate existing pools of U.S. healthcare talent will likely get more value from the platform's domain-specific intelligence than they would from a general-purpose recruiting CRM. Organizations hiring across multiple industries or internationally, however, may find that focus too limiting, though we are told several still opt to use the tool for its forward-looking AI capabilities and robustness.

Hellora Customers

Fairview Health, BrightSpring Health Services, BJC Health System, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Compassus Home Health, Children's Health, PetVet, VHC Healthcare.

Hellora Pricing

Custom.

How has Hellora Changed Over Time?

Best For

U.S.-based healthcare organizations managing thousands of employees and substantial candidate databases.

Hellora in action
No items found.

Recruiterflow

Visit Website
Recruiterflow
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.2 / 5
User Score
4.5 / 5
Product Score
4.1 / 5

Why we picked Recruiterflow

If you find Bullhorn too expensive, Recruiterflow can be a great alternative. This recruitment CRM software is cheaper, super easy to use, and has one of the best talent nurture automation features in the space.

PROS

  • Multi-channel engagement via email, SMS and calls with Twilio integration
  • Auto data enrichment with LinkedIn and Gmail integration
  • Advanced Boolean search for precise candidate targeting
  • Intuitive enough for non-tech-savvy recruiters
  • Candidate engagement efforts are possible via email, SMS campaigns, and phone calls (Twilio integration required).
  • Auto data enrichment capabilities with LinkedIn and Gmail integration.
  • Advanced Boolean search for precise candidate targeting.
  • Easy to use for non-tech-savvy recruiters.

CONS

  • No native mobile app, PWA only
  • Occasional glitches during application setup
  • Automatic profile enrichment excluded from Base plan
  • Most automation features locked behind Advanced plan
  • No native mobile app is currently available, only a PWA.
  • Some minor glitches with the application setup process.
  • Automatic profile enrichment is not included in the Base plan.
  • Most automation features are only available in the Advanced plan.
Recruiterflow-recruiting-crm-software-dashboard

Recruiterflow Review

Recruiterflow is like a Bullhorn version yet made for smaller staffing agencies—it doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a custom plan, but it's way cheaper and, from my experience, easier to work with.

I’ve tested and am pleased with the platform’s Advanced Search. This feature supports Boolean, radius search (with Google Maps integration behind the scenes), and custom filters. You can (and definitely should) combine that with the system's engagement features, as this will give you a powerful combo to one: segment your talent database into smaller communities and two: nurture these communities with email sequences that resonate and go out at the right time.

Another thing I like about using Recruiterflow is its "Recipes" feature. Think about how much time you could save by automating actions like auto-adding candidates who haven't heard from you in 90 days to your nurturing campaign. Or, you could set a rule so that an email introducing new placements lands in the inboxes of vetted candidates who weren't picked by clients each month. Very cool, isn’t it?

There’s no denying this platform is user-friendly, but the Help Center content is not as detailed as what I've seen from other vendors like Manatal. Some of the features also seem to arrive much later than what their competitors have. For example, they didn't even have star-rating candidate profiles until June 2024. However, I'm happy to share that they've recently added AI candidate matching. It felt like quite the wait, but thankfully, it’s been well worth it.

Recruiterflow Customers

1,000+ recruitment firms, including RepVue, Total Aviation Staffing, and Johnson Search Group.

Recruiterflow Pricing

Recruiterflow pricing is between $85 and $99 per user per month for the base plan, depending on whether you pay annually or monthly. There is also a free trial with no credit card info required.

How has Recruiterflow Changed Over Time?

Best For

Recruiting and staffing agencies looking for an affordable, user-friendly solution to manage and nurture their talent pools.

Recruiterflow in action
No items found.

Crelate

Visit Website
Crelate
Learn More
Popularity Score
4.1 / 5
User Score
4.4 / 5
Product Score
4.2 / 5

Why we picked Crelate

Testing Crelate and it became apparent to me that this CRM tool has one of the best search features. It’s not only robust but super flexible. You can perform quick, fast searches, more complicated ones, and even filter within a specific email campaign.

PROS

  • Supports quick lookup, full-text search, Boolean logic, and custom filters.
  • Ability to add unique Boolean groupings within the filters and columns within Search.
  • Engagement channels available via email, phone, and SMS.
  • Supports quick lookup, full-text search, Boolean logic, and custom filters.
  • Ability to add unique Boolean groupings within the filters and columns within Search.
  • Engagement channels available via email, phone, and SMS.

CONS

  • No free plan is available, though a free trial is offered.
  • Interface is quite dated and less user-friendly compared to competitors.
  • Contact data enrichment is an add-on (read: cost extra).
  • No free plan or free trial.
  • Interface is quite dated and less user-friendly compared to competitors.
  • Contact data enrichment is an add-on (read: cost extra).
Crelate-recruiting-software-dashboard

Crelate Review

Crelate's UI is not my cup of tea as compared to competitors, it looks rather old-fashioned and complicated. But when I tried this platform’s search feature, it was a whole different story. The Search isn’t just robust but also super flexible. For starters, you can choose which quick-filter tiles—those at the top of the dashboard that let you turn different filters on and off—you want to see on this view.

Functionality-wise, this feature enables you to search and filter through your resumes, notes, and tags. Like most recruiting CRM I’ve picked on this page, Crelate also let me do both simple, quick lookups and Boolean logic for more complex queries. Something unique about this feature that you probably won’t find elsewhere is the ability to search and filter at the campaign level. I can actually use criteria like status and date range to narrow down my search results within a specific campaign. How cool is that?

I like the efficiency of Crelate’s profile enrichment tool—it alone can auto-collect several essential talent data points, from phone numbers to email addresses and new employers. Yet, the way it’s marketed is kind of disappointing. Unlike many others that allow most users to have this feature for free, with Crelate, you’ll have to buy it as an add-on to be able to use it.

If you're looking for a corporate-focused solution with great mobile apps, I don’t think you should go with this tool, either. Crelate has always focused on staffing agencies, and its mobile apps don't offer as many features as the browser version.

Crelate Customers

1,700+ recruitment agencies, including RedfoxTM, Ambassador Search Group, and Extra Effort Solutions, Inc.

Crelate Pricing

Crelate has three plans: Essential ($85 per user per month), Business ($119 per user per month), Business Plus (custom pricing), and Enterprise plan (custom pricing).

How has Crelate Changed Over Time?

Best For

Mid-size recruiting firms and staffing agencies.

Crelate in action
Reviewer's Rating
5/10

During periods with a high number of open roles, I used Crelate daily. I primarily used it as a database for job postings and applicant tracking. It functioned as the system of record for recruiting activities.

I used it to manage incoming applicants and to proactively reach out to potential candidates. I ran reports when needed to support hiring decisions and track activity.

What do you like about Crelate?
  • Crelate allows direct communication with candidates through the system.
  • It offers useful customization features.
  • It distributes job postings to external job boards.
Why did your organization buy Crelate, and how long have you used it for?

I worked at this company for over five years, and Crelate was already in place when I started. I used it for just over five years, from my start date through my departure. The organization selected this tool to manage recruiting activities in a cost-effective way.

A key benefit was the pay-as-you-use pricing model, with quarterly invoicing that was relatively inexpensive compared to many other applicant tracking systems. Once users became familiar with the platform, it was straightforward to use.

What do you dislike about Crelate?
  • Crelate’s reporting features are limited.
  • The platform feels clunky and is less user-friendly than other ATS platforms I have used.
  • Customer service was often slow to respond, sometimes taking days and requiring follow-up.
How is Crelate different than their competitors?

If I am being honest, Crelate is my least preferred ATS. It does not compare favorably with many of its competitors in terms of usability and reporting capabilities. If given a choice, I would select a different platform.

What Instructions should people think about when buying this type of tool?

Consider your budget and recruiting volume. This system may be appropriate for organizations with a smaller budget and limited hiring needs, such as a few open positions per year.

How has Crelate changed or evolved over time to meet users needs?

I did not observe significant changes during the five years I used it. There were no major updates or improvements that stood out.

What specific type of user or organization is Crelate very good for?

Crelate is good for small to mid-sized firms with lighter recruiting volume and an in-house HR team.

What specific type of user or organization would Crelate not be a good fit for?

A large company with high recruiting volume will not find Crelate robust enough.

Key Features to Look for in a Recruitment CRM

When researching the best CRM software for recruiting, you may find that some fall short in one or a few of the following five, but offer something else as an alternative. I wouldn't recommend going for such tools, though. In my experience, while some features may seem attractive at first, talent database, engagement, workflow automation, reporting, and integrations are truly the core ones that one will regret treating as add-ons.

  • Candidate database: To build and maintain good candidate relationships, you need a solid candidate database. To be considered solid, this feature should: 1) be a central hub for candidate information and 2) have a user-friendly interface, be it accessing the talent pool in a mobile app, automatically sourcing candidates with pre-defined and custom criteria, enriching profiles with a click on a button or via a Chrome extension, syncing data between the CRM and ATS, or removing any duplicate entries.
  • Communication management: A strong candidate database won't be much use if you don't have the right tools to communicate with your contacts effectively. In-house tools like branding, engagement templates, landing pages for lead capture, interview scheduling, and social media marketing are worth exploring, as they help ensure you engage with top talent in the best way possible.
  • Workflow automation: To effectively engage with your talent pool, you'll need suitable content for each drip campaign or audience segment. Doing all of these manually can take several hours a day. Plus, timing matters, especially when your candidates are from multiple time zones. Top recruitment CRM software, via personalization, segmentation, and automation, can lighten the load and help you reach and follow up with candidates with the right message and at the right time.
  • Analytics and reporting: Don't underestimate the power of using data to improve your recruitment efforts. You can't create an engagement strategy that works for every type of candidate you have, but with the help of the right system, you can easily sort and mine data, track conversions and sources in real-time, and identify trends and patterns to adjust your engagements in ways that work for most of your talent pool.
  • Integration capabilities: From messy and scattered talent data to a slow hiring process and ineffective communication, a standalone candidate management system can really mess up your recruitment efforts. On the other hand, a collaborative CRM offers intuitive integrations with job boards, your Outlook/Gmail, HRIS, ATS, onboarding tools, and other HR and recruiting systems your team uses, whether native or via Zapier. This, in turn, streamlines and tidies up the entire data synchronization process across all your platforms[1].

Benefits of Using a Recruiting CRM Software

Key benefits a top candidate relationship management tool can bring to your organization include talent pooling, enhanced candidate experience, and recruitment efficiency, and better data-informed hiring decisions

  • Talent pool nurturing: One of the best things about using a recruitment CRM is its capability to manage and nurture talent for both current and future hiring needs. With the application of AI in recruitment tech, you can expect top-notch CRM solutions to engage talent more efficiently without compromising quality.
  • Better candidate experience: Getting SMS/emails about job postings that really match what they are looking for in their career change, being able to apply straight from their phones, and getting timely updates on their application progress—these are some of the perks a user-friendly recruiting CRM platform can offer to make your candidate job search easier and more personalized.
  • Recruiting efficiency boost: Most talent CRM platforms today come with recruitment process automation, AI-driven features, and integration capabilities. Choosing a good one means you won't have to spend hours each day manually searching for potential candidate profiles and reaching out to them one by one. You can also automate talent nurturing and be confident that the CRM will keep all your talent data synced across your HR systems.
  • More data-driven decisions: Recruitment solutions, including the CRM category, have become a lot smarter over the past few years. Besides the ability to produce customizable reports, these platforms can now offer real-time HR analytics to help users detect when a passive candidate is open to a job opportunity, which position you’re hiring for may interest them, and even what message will really grab their attention[2]—all to help you make good, informed decisions when engaging with talent.

Pro Tips on Recruiting CRM

CRM vs. ATS: How These Two Differ

The core difference between a recruiting CRM and an ATS lies in their focus. CRM focuses on building and maintaining candidate relationships for long-term engagement, while ATS is specifically tailored to manage the application process and workflow for open positions within the organization. These two recruiting platforms can be used independently or integrated to optimize the entire recruitment process.

However, a trend we’re seeing is that the line between these two types of recruitment software is becoming blurred, with more vendors striving to make their product a complete, end-to-end solution by integrating a CRM into their core ATS or vice versa.

For instance, Greenhouse introduced its CRM 5 years after its ATS product (and has since made some acquisitions to enhance this new offering), while platforms like Manatal and Zoho Recruit launched both their ATS and CRM at around the same time when they entered the market. Or more recently, Gem, a household name in talent sourcing tools, launched its ATS, built on the solid foundation of its CRM software.

Differences between recruiting CRM and ATS

Who Recruiting CRM is Not for

Recruiting CRM software may not be ideal if you need to hire only occasionally, for gig roles, or if you experience high turnover.

  • The hiring need is short-term: Since recruiting CRM software is meant for long-term talent management, investing in it for short-term needs won’t be the best use of your resources. Teaming up with staffing and recruitment agencies that specialize in filling short-term placements might make a lot more sense to you.
  • Your team relies heavily on gig workers: As recruitment CRM is more geared toward full-time hires, you likely won’t find this tool suitable in this case, either. Instead, you might want to use freelancer management systems like Upwork or Fiverr for project-based work and job advertising platforms that focus on gig roles.
  • Your recruitment team faces high turnover: Constantly training new TAs and recruiters doesn't just take up a lot of time and money. It can also lead to messy data entry and inconsistent use of recruiting CRM software. In this situation, it's really important to focus on keeping your recruitment teams happy and motivated above everything else.

Recruitment CRM Best Practices

A recruitment CRM solution is for teams that want to manage candidate data and nurture their talent database over time but don’t necessarily want to sacrifice lots of time and effort for manual, complicated data hygiene and engagement setups. Retail recruiting, DEI recruiting, and manufacturing recruiting are among the top use cases for recruiting CRM systems.

  • Retail Recruiting[3]: For retailers looking to enhance the shopping experience during the holiday season, recruiting CRM software can greatly help with creating career pages and lead capture forms in-store to connect with potential part-time staff. Given students make up a fair share of social media platform users, retailers can also use the CRM to run email, SMS, and social media campaigns that deliver job openings and product promotions to the right audience.
  • Diversity Hiring: Recruiting CRM platforms can help employers practice DEI recruitment through targeted, multi-channel recruitment marketing. With advanced search and an organized database, you can identify specific talent communities and then use personalized emails, landing pages, and social media to engage these diverse talent groups. Further, these software solutions can assist you in identifying recruitment strategies and sources that have brought in high-quality, diverse employees.
  • Manufacturing Recruitment: Open house events and connections with local colleges and apprenticeship programs can help get future workers interested in manufacturing careers, and a recruitment CRM system is an excellent tool for storing and keeping these contacts engaged. By syncing their existing HRIS/HCM/HRMS and career fair platforms to the recruiting CRM, these businesses can also cultivate talent pools of internal prospects, set up career expos, and run nurture programs to encourage relocation, all to meet staffing needs for their facilities.

How Much Does Recruiting CRM Software Cost?

Recruiting CRM pricing varies and depends on factors such as the number of users, active jobs, feature sets, and customer support. Most providers offer subscription-based models, with pricing typically ranging from $15 to $129 per user per month. Some providers may also offer custom enterprise pricing plans for larger organizations.

Below is a comparison table of top recruiting CRM software prices.

  Recruiting CRM

  Pricing (Annual Billing)

  Gem

 Eligible startups: First 6 months free, then 50% off the first paid year.

 Internal recruiters:

  • 1-10 FTE company at $135/month. 
  • 11-30 FTE company at $180/month.
  • 31-50 FTE company at $225/month.
  • 51-75 FTE company at $315/month.
  • 76-100 FTE company at $405/month.

 Staffing firms:

  • Essentials at $99/user/month for up to 3 users.
  • Professional at $149/user/month for up to 10 users.
  • Enterprise: custom pricing.

 Free trial available.

  Recruit CRM

 Base plans:

  • Pro: $100 per user/month
  • Business: $150 per user/month
  • Enterprise: $165 per user/month

 Optional Add-ons:

  • Workflow Automation: $41/month (includes 1,000 tasks per user)
  • Job Multiposting and Advertising: $20/month (for up to 7 jobs)
  • Data Enrichment: $20/month (for 3,000 credits)
  • LinkedIn Messages Integration: $12/user/month
  • Advanced Analytics: $25/user/month
  • Recruit Craft: $41/month

 Free trial available.

  Humanly

 Starts at $1,000 per month. No free trial.

  SmartRecruiters

 Starts at $14,995. No free trial.

  Bullhorn

 Starts at $199 per month. No free trial.

  Manatal

  • Professional: $15 per user/month.
  • Enterprise: $35 per user/month.
  • Enterprise Plus: $55 per user/month.
  • Custom: Custom pricing.

 Free trial available.

  Loxo

  • Free: $0 for one user.
  • Basic: $169 per user/month.
  • Professional: Custom pricing.
  • Enterprise: Custom pricing.

 Free trial available.

  JobAdder

 Starts at $160 per month. No free trial.

  Recruiterflow

  • Advanced Plan: $119 per user/month.
  • Custom: Custom pricing.

 Free trial available.

  Crelate

  • Business: $119 per user/month.
  • Business Plus: Custom pricing.
  • Enterprise: Custom pricing.

 Free trial available.

Best CRM for Staffing Agencies

Here are some top candidate relationship management tools for staffing firms:

  • Bullhorn: A household name in the recruitment staffing software space, highly customized automation for re-engaging candidates in your ATS.
  • Recruiterflow: A very intuitive CRM option with excellent talent nurture automation capabilities.
  • Recruit CRM: Perfect for small and midsize staffing agencies, this tool is very well priced and constantly expanding its CRM feature list.

FAQs

What is a CRM in recruitment?

Holm (2012) noted digital recruitment made candidate communication central, calling it “candidate relationship management.” In practice, recruiting CRM is a tech category that provides pipeline management, automated campaigns, and talent segmentation. These tools focus on the pre-application phase, building awareness, interest, and engagement with passive candidates[4].

How do organizations use CRM for recruiting?

Organizations across industries mainly use recruitment CRM software to build lasting relationships with potential talent via frequent outreach, check-ins, and nurturing campaigns. More recently, as this solution has evolved to include ATS features, more companies are leveraging it to track candidates, run employee referrals, and perform resume parsing. The goal is to consolidate all recruitment activities into a single, user-friendly dashboard for easy management.

How does recruitment CRM work?

The recruiting CRM process involves capturing relevant information about potential candidates to understand their career aspirations and expectations. It involves all the steps that an employer or a staffing agency takes to build long-lasting candidate relationships. Depending on each vendor, it may also encompass all the touchpoints in a candidate's lifecycle—from outreach to job application and onboarding.

What is the best Recruitment CRM software for small businesses?

The following are some free and cheap recruitment CRM platforms SMBs can consider:

  • Manatal: Starts at $15 per user per month, billed annually. 14-day free trial available.
  • Recruit CRM: Starts at $49 per user per month, billed annually. Free trial available.
  • Zoho Recruit: Starts at $25 per user per month, billed annually. Free plan available.

Are there any free recruiting CRM systems?

Yes, they are, though not many. Recruit CRM, Zoho Recruit, and Giig each have a free version you can use for as long as you want, while vendors like Manatal give you free access to their recruitment CRM features for a limited period. Also, if you don’t mind a bit of workaround, the popular customer relationship management tool HubSpot is free to use and can function as a pretty good CRM for recruitment purposes.

Was It Worth Your Time?

Choosing the perfect recruiting CRM software can be quite a task, especially if you're just diving into this area. I hope this guide has given you all the insights you need to make the right call.

Before we wrap up, anything you wish I had covered here? Reach out here or LinkedIn me—you’re doing me a huge favor by keeping the guide as helpful and on-point as possible.

References

About the Author

Anh Nguyen
Ex-Tech Recruiter, Senior HR Tech Researcher, Writer & Editor
LinkedIn logoTwitter logo

Anh Nguyen researches how hiring, payroll, and compliance rules shift, often unpredictably, from one labor market to the next, and how much of that complexity gets hidden from the people making buying decisions. She has been a Human Resources (HR) Tech Researcher, Writer & Editor at SelectSoftware Reviews since 2022, following three years recruiting for tech startups and enterprises in Singapore, Australia, India, the UK, the US, and Vietnam, work that put her on the inside of the exact problems she now writes about.

Her research spans four areas: candidate assessment and sourcing technology; global employment infrastructure, including Employer of Record (EOR), Professional Employer Organization (PEO), staffing agency, and payroll systems; the application of artificial intelligence (AI) to hiring and workforce decisions, from resume prescreening through performance evaluation; and hiring bias, diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), and recruitment ethics, including pay transparency and discriminatory hiring practices.

She has evaluated 120+ HR and recruiting platforms and published 90+ articles and reviews. Her country-level analysis of global employment infrastructure covers the UK, Canada, Singapore, India, Australia, and the Philippines. She co-authors SelectSoftware Reviews' quarterly HR Tech Trend Reports and has produced six editions of its Applicant Tracking System (ATS) and Human Resource Information System (HRIS) reports.

Outside SelectSoftware Reviews, Anh researches and speaks on digital transformation and the application of AI in organizational and educational settings.

When she's not working, Anh is usually with her family, writing for her personal blog, or out running with her two dogs, who are laid-back until the moment they decide the run is actually a race.

Her work has been cited by HR tech publications such as Dice, ERE Media, e27, Human Resources Director (HRD),  HR Executive, Recruiting Daily, Staffing Industry Analysts (SIA), theHRDirector, and The Philadelphia Inquirer.

About Us

  • Our goal at SSR is to help HR and recruiting teams to find and buy the right software for their needs.
  • Our site is free to use as some vendors will pay us for web traffic.
  • SSR lists all companies we feel are top vendors - not just those who pay us - in our comprehensive directories full of the advice needed to make the right purchase decision for your HR team.

Get expert advice on

Get in touch with

Step 1 of 2

How many employees are in your company?

Thank you!
We'll get in touch with you shortly.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
100% free service
Customized recommendations
1 on 1 help
No items found.