//this is the mailchimp popup form //ShareThis code for sharing images
Home / Blog / The HR Trust Gap: Why Employees Stay Silent About Workplace Discrimination

The HR Trust Gap: Why Employees Stay Silent About Workplace Discrimination

Why Employees Stay Silent About Workplace Discrimination

Kayleigh Hansen
HR & payroll SMB-focused professional, HR Trends & Tech Expert
Contributing Experts
Why Employees Stay Silent About Workplace Discrimination
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Contributing Experts

Table of Contents

Share this article

Subscribe to weekly updates

Join 20,000 HR Tech Nerds who get our weekly insights
Thanks for signing up, we send our newsletter every Wednesday at 10 AM ET!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
20 Best Employee Rewards Platforms of 2026, Tested & Compared

Employees don't always report workplace discrimination. Sometimes they stay quiet, sometimes they start looking for another job, and sometimes they decide the process of speaking up isn't worth the trouble.

So what makes employees hesitate to come forward? And when someone does raise a concern, how can HR respond in a way that actually helps?

During SSR's HR Legal AMA series, employment attorney Heather Bussing shared her perspective on why employees stay silent, the challenges HR faces when handling complaints, and why curiosity can be more productive than immediately going on the defensive.

Q: Why do employees choose not to report workplace discrimination, even when they're experiencing it?

Heather: "The truth is, most people are not going to report it, just like women don't report sexual harassment or assault. And that's because they don't want to have to live with this situation while it goes through the investigation and all of the things. They'd rather just lay low and try to get out and get somewhere else where they're appreciated and not discriminated against, because that is the path of least resistance.

When you have experienced discrimination, you know that organizations have a conflict of interest, and HR has a conflict of interest because they're charged with protecting the company, the organization, the employer.

When they're dealing with discrimination, they're supposed to both be open and objective and caring toward the person who feels discriminated against, and protect the organization to the extent possible. And that never results in a resolution."

Q: How does that conflict of interest affect the way discrimination complaints are handled?

Heather: "The people who are discriminating usually don't think they are and feel attacked. And if they have more power than the person being discriminated against, which is almost always the case, it doesn't resolve.

You end up with the person leaving, either because they need to or want to, as sort of the settlement of the situation. But the one thing that employers are really resistant to doing is actually dealing with the manager or the person who is the problem.

This is just the way it always goes because of that inherent conflict between protecting the victim and protecting the company when there's an adversarial situation. The best approach is to try and get everyone on the same side of the table and go, 'How do we solve this problem?' But if it involves somebody with power, it's almost impossible."

Q: What's the biggest mistake HR can make when an employee comes forward with a complaint?

Heather: "The very first human instinct is to blame the person for the problem, and that is the worst place you can start, even when it's true.

It's often true because  when you hear about it, it's been festering for a long time. Everybody has convinced themselves that they're right and that they're being treated unfairly, and sometimes that comes out as discrimination. 'I'm being discriminated against,' because unfair can be legal, but discrimination isn't.

People know that if they want attention or action, they have to create a crisis. Let's dial the crisis button down.

The biggest thing you can do is listen and be curious and put yourself in that person's shoes and try to figure out what's actually going on. A lot of times, it's not about what it's about. In fact, mostly, it's not about what it's about. You can't solve the problem until you get to the bottom of what it's about. And that takes some trust and some time and some compassion."

Q: How should HR approach a complaint when the situation doesn't meet the legal definition of discrimination or harassment?

Heather: "Congratulations. You've figured that out. Don't stop there, because there's still a problem here. There's still a problem. You wouldn't be hearing about this unless there was a problem.

It may be the employee trying to buy time because they're having performance issues, or it may be that you've got a manager who's really difficult. And even though it doesn't cross the line of discrimination, it's dysfunctional.

Don't stop at the discrimination determination. Take a step further to see what's actually going on and whether there's a path through that. Otherwise, it's just going to get worse, and you're not going to be done with it anyway."

Q: When a complaint comes in, should HR focus on the investigation or on resolving the underlying issue?

Heather: "When a claim comes in, you have an opportunity to go adversarial or to get curious. My advice is to get curious. If you want to be right or win, the opportunity to solve the problem comes off the table.

I try not to think about it from a legal standpoint. I try to think about it from a human standpoint and figure out what's actually going on, because from a business standpoint, you would rather solve the problem than escalate it to a dispute."

Q: What can HR do when employees are afraid to speak up or don't trust the process?

Heather: "The best approach is to try and get everyone on the same side of the table and go, 'How do we solve this problem?'"

Be curious and put yourself in that person's shoes and try to figure out what's actually going on. You can't solve the problem until you kind of get to the bottom of what it's about. And that takes some trust and some time and some compassion."

Continue the conversation

Want to hear more from Heather Bussing? Watch SSR's HR Legal AMA: How to Address Workplace Discrimination and Harassment and HR Legal AMA Part 2: Addressing Workplace Discrimination and Harassment for additional insights on workplace discrimination, employee complaints, investigations, and the legal challenges HR professionals navigate every day.

A note on legal guidance:

Heather Bussing is an experienced employment attorney. This interview is intended for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Employment laws vary by jurisdiction and individual circumstances. Always consult your organization's legal counsel or a qualified employment attorney when addressing workplace discrimination complaints, investigations, or potential retaliation.

‍

Kayleigh Hansen
HR & payroll SMB-focused professional, HR Trends & Tech Expert
LinkedIn logoTwitter logo

Kayleigh Hansen is the Virtual Events Manager at SelectSoftware Reviews, where she leads webinar and virtual programming for HR and people operations professionals. She holds a BA in Digital & Print Journalism from the University of North Texas.

With over 8 years of marketing experience—including 4 years in HR tech and people ops—Kayleigh has specialized in virtual events, content syndication, and building content networks that connect HR leaders with valuable insights and solutions. Her experience working on the HR tech side gives her a strong understanding of the challenges HR teams face and what they’re looking to learn and improve.

Based in the Dallas–Fort Worth area, Kayleigh enjoys hand embroidery, crafting, and hosting get-togethers. Connect with her on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kayleighhansen/

Looking for HR Software? Get Free Quotes: